Apple, Analysts and the iPad 2:The Apple of their Eyes

“Apple remains the best technology company on the planet.”

“This is a sad day (The day Apple released iPad 2) for the crowd of competitors.”

“The day could not have gone better”

“Comparable tablets will need to price meaningfully below the iPad in order to take share in this market – an event that is highly unlikely given that they would essentially be breaking-even or losing money at those prices.”

(Image Courtesy –

You could be forgiven for thinking that an Apple flak penned the above lines. That, however, would be no closer to the truth, than Apple’s nearest rivals are to catching up with the tech giant.

These are, in fact, the carefully considered and meticulously measured words of various brokerages, that they issued in response to Apple’s launch of the iPad 2 on March 2.
READ REUTERS REPORT : Apple’s Jobs puts on lively iPad 2 show

It makes me wonder why ever Apple would need to spend a single penny on public relations. With analysts so deeply in love with the company and its array of blockbuster products, who needs the services of a public relations officer?

An Omnicom’s Interbrand brand consultancy division report shows that Apple products were placed in 10 of the top 30 Hollywood films in 2010. And that is actually down from 50 percent in 2008, and 44 percent in 2009! I find it amusing that while on one side Apple coughs up hundreds and thousands of dollars to project their company/products favourably, brokerages/analysts are willing to afford them stellar coverage, in most cases for free!

Frankly, analysts seem to have let down their guard. People who usually jump at the faintest sign of weakness in a company’s balance sheet, commentary, outlook and are wont to keep their comments guarded, brief and lined with caveats, suddenly seem to be outdoing each other in waxing eloquent. Some of their comments and the general sense of the whole of their notes belie the fact that these are the guys that investors are relying on to do a critical evaluation of the company.

And if you are still not convinced about Apple’s love affair with stock analysts just take a look at the brokerage recommendations.

Of the 54 analysts surveyed by Thomson Reuters 50 have a “buy” or a “strong buy” rating on the stock. That’s a staggering 93 percent. I doubt if I could get my blood relatives to confess their love for me so unanimously.

Even if Apple is in truth all it is touted to be, it is unhealthy and dangerous for analysts — the people we trust to study and analyse the company in an objective manner – to be so lyrically adulatory and in such a unanimous manner at that.

A part of the reason why analysts love Apple so may lie with Apple’s successful gadgets but a lot has to do with Jobs. In a note an analyst went so far as to say, “Yesterday Apple and Steve Jobs introduced the iPad 2.”

Clearly Steve Jobs being on the stage for the launch is almost as fascinating an idea as the company’s new product itself. A fantastic case of “the Man “ and “the Machine” coming together to take a company to heady heights.

To my mind the obvious reason (legitimate or otherwise) for the way analysts adulate Apple and Jobs, is their success. Nothing succeeds like success. Success, however, may be fleeting and one must be alert to the possibility of things going wrong. The “truly, madly and deeply in love” tone of most of the analyst notes can hardly be the end result of a critical, alert and objective approach.

Whether it is the charisma of Steve Jobs or the sheer magic of its products Apple certainly has stock analysts wrapped around its little finger.

It is for lesser companies to shell out oodles of cash on splashy advertising campaigns and carefully thought out promotional events. All Apple needs to do is to have Steve Jobs take the stage with whatever it is that the company is launching.

And then the company can sit back and enjoy the applause.

(The writing above does not reflect anything but my own personal views.)



  1. Divya Sharma
    Posted March 4, 2011 at 7:03 pm | Permalink | Reply

    will be wise to get some buy-side views on Apple for the “critical, alert and objective approach” you are looking for if you think analysts’ enthusiasm is over-hyped…

  2. Shadan
    Posted March 7, 2011 at 1:53 am | Permalink | Reply

    “to be Lyrically adulatory….” 🙂 what a fantastic view on the geeky analyst…people who even eat analyzing the forecast of the price of the food…you have turned them into helpless lovers of Mr.Jobs… great job..indeed it is fresh writing..

    Coming to facts…Analysts are so all praises for Apple, because of its consistency in innovating,delivering superior products and above all taking markets and competitors by surprise consistently…while other companies still trying to launch an answer to Ipad1, Jobs goes ahead and kills the competition..launches Ipad2..hence the market confidence on Apple..

    • saqib ahmed
      Posted March 8, 2011 at 5:53 pm | Permalink | Reply

      True. But am not arguing whether Apple is ‘great’ or not. Am just saying as analysts please be objective. Don’t go ” Apple is the greatest thing since sliced bread! Oooh La La!”

  3. Tanveer
    Posted March 8, 2011 at 3:03 pm | Permalink | Reply

    “I doubt if I could get my blood relatives to confess their love for me so unanimously.”

    ….. Would not find any problem in them taking up an opposite stand!!! 🙂

    • saqib ahmed
      Posted March 8, 2011 at 5:53 pm | Permalink | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: